Shh! Don't talk too loudly. We're at a crime scene! The only way to solve "whodunnit" is by applying your finely-honed skills collecting evidence, and coming up with insightful explanations to support a reasonable claim. Did I say "reasonable claim?" I meant, to solve a murder and make the streets safe again.
Take a moment to peruse the crime scene photographs that will serve as the cornerstone of our "close read" materials.
NextGen Learning Standards: 8R1, 8R3, 8W7, 8SL5
We'll start out by reviewing exactly what it means to observe and infer. We'll present a Slides presentation describing the difference between the two skills, and then watch a Sherlock Holmes clip to see what he observes, and watch his precise reasoning come to incredibly logical inferences.
After watching Sherlock show us how it's done, we'll take a quick assessment to make sure everyone understands the two skills before starting to watch our NCIS episode.
NextGen Learning Standards: 8R1, 8R3, 8W2, 8W7, 8SL5
We'll spend the remainder of the two in-person days learning observation and inference from the best in the business: Shawn Spencer! In this television episode, you'll see him carefully collect evidence and make logical inferences based on what he finds! Eventually, through careful observation and inference, he's able to put together all the pieces to tell a story that makes sense, and inevitably reflects the truth. We'll start by learning how to observe and infer, and how to use our observation and inference graphic organizer, before watching the episode in 8:00-12:00 increments, annotating our observations and inferences together.
NextGen Learning Standards: 8R4, 8W1c, 8W2c, 8L4
As with all learning, there are just some words you need to be able to know, and easily use before any unit can start. The words to the right are sometimes easy for students (those tend to be the students who watch crime shows) and are completely random nonsense for other students (who don't watch crime shows.) We'll start by using a modified digital vocabulary technique piloted by a coworker, and then doing a response-card activity with the murder mystery words. We won't cross a word out until EVERYONE in class can identify it.
NextGen Learning Standards: 8R1, 8R3, 8R6, 8R8, 8R9, 8W1, 8W6, 8W7, 8SL1, 8SL4, 8SL5
On these two days, students will perform their gallery walk, and finish their observation / inference graphic organizer. Everyone will start by closely reading the murder scenario to the left, and then spend about ten minutes at each station to collect as much information as possible.
This week is when we're doing the heavy lifting of crafting our evidence-based claim. We'll devote a single day to discussion of the suspect alternatives, and a second day to turning our observation / inference graphic organizer into a well-explained evidence-based claim in which students will decide who committed the crime.
NextGen Learning Standards: 8R1, 8R3, 8R6, 8R8, 8R9, 8W1, 8W6, 8W7, 8SL1, 8SL4, 8SL5
We'll finish our work this week by publishing our Evidence-Based Claims into a Google Slides format to aid in our oral presentations next week. As with all the work we do together during 8th grade ELA, the better students Observation / Inference sheet, the easier the discussion. The more engaged the discussion, the easier the EBC graphic organizer. The better the writing on the EBC graphic organizer, the easier and better the beautiful Slides presentation they create, and the better the Slides, the easier it is to present an oral presentation.
NextGen Learning Standards: 8W4, 8W5, 8W6, 8W7, 8SL1, 8SL2, 8SL4, 8SL5, 8SL6, 8L6
Our first day this week will be spent finishing up, or in some cases, improving and refining our Slides presentations and rehearsing for our oral presentations tomorrow.
During our second day in person, students will spend their time presenting their finding to their peers! I get to sit back and enjoy while students do all the heavy lifting today.
You've watched the experts do it. You've observed, you've inferred, you've summarized. It's time to set you free to examine a crime scene of your own! Use all the skills you've learned to objectively collect the evidence. Decide what's important to know, and what information is useless. Use the vocabulary you've practiced to focus on what matters most, and of course, be prepared to write some amazing crime-scene analysis to present to your classmates.
In this project, students will complete a gallery walk with six stations describing a heinous crime. They'll need to use all the skills they've practiced this unit to complete a second observation / inference sheet, and then to organize those annotations into an evidence-based claim in which they'll prove who committed the murder! Final work will be published as a Google Slides to accompany their presentation.
Collect, analyze, and organize evidence in an authentic setting: [8R1, 8R3]
Evaluate arguments, claims, and evidence for effectiveness and thoroughness: [8R6, 8R8]
Write an evidence-based claim paragraph based on crime-scene research: [8W1, 8W6]
Discuss alternative theories and orally present final evidence based claim to classmates: [8SL1, 8SL1a, 8SL3, 8SL48SL6]
It's all fun and games until someone gets murdered...If you want to see some of our more serious units, look into our work with Unconscious Bias or see how we use our writing skills to master short stories or free-verse poetry.